Background:
http://www.news.com.au/business/online-sales-will-kill-jobs-retailers/comments-e6frfm1i-1225981373508
Currently in the news, eCommerce is all the go in Australia. Our dollar is 1-to-1 with the American dollar, and Australian’s are reaching out, globalising their purchasing. Add the cost of shipping, quite high to Australia, and the deals are still great.
There is however, no 10% GST on imported purchases under $1000. The local market is calling foul. The fact is, add 10% to the purchase price, and the Aussie market still can’t compete….
Remember, you are also already paying a big shipping premium,$20-$60?
A big part of the problem is retail rental rates. So, you have to feel for the industry - rock, hard place, all that….
Issues to the public:
Retailers in Australia are naturally concerned, seeing their revenues going to overseas online competitors. So, they are pressuring the government to protect their interests. Recap: They send the Aussie jobs overseas to China because they are cheaper, yet scream foul and ‘Un Australianism” when those now otherwise employed people purchase overseas because they are looking for a better deal.
Meyer can buy a pair of Jeans in China (because Aussie labour is too expensive) for $5 and sell them here for $120. Now, a consumer (who used to work in Textiles, but now has a lower paying retail job) can buy those same Jeans from the ‘States for $45, plus $25 Shipping. Ain’t globalisation a bitch…
This fundamental hypocrisy of the local retail complaint is not lost on the public.
Additionally, watching the Aussie dollar go from .60 to 1.0 against the US dollar, and not seeing notable price reductions is an issue. It lets us all know who is getting a sweet bite on the cherry.
Add the fact that most retailers are no longer hiring knowledgeable salespeople, but rather whomever will work for the part-time package they offer. So, don’t even ask where something is, much less how it works. They handle transactions OK though…
Their posturing about “Saving Australian Jobs” isn’t working very well in light of these realities.
Brand:
Harvey Norman has always had a great brand image, capturing the unique sweet spot in Australian culture, “The Battler.” The little guy doing well against the odds. Personable, approachable, just like us. Our mates. Same as St George Bank has carried well.
Problem is, Gerry Harvey has just burned his Brand, and with Web 2.0 you can see it happening before your eyes. Gerry is in the news, and the commentary is blistering. Twitter is going off on him.
In his attempt to garner better revenue, he may have lost the baby with the bathwater. He has just put himself into the same boardroom as David Jones, Meyer and Target, and low and behold, he’s the spokesperson. Bad move Gerry.
Now, St George Bank, that’s an interesting counterpoint. Now owed by NAB, one of the “Big Banks” the St George brand has been kept alive, not merged. While NAB can boost rates above the Reserve Bank rate, and stand equal with the other big banks, sharing the damage. St George never comes up. Sure, St George rates go up, after the news cycle on interest rates passes. St George brand is still “the Battler” even if it has long since ceased being the reality.
Gerry Harvey has always been the strength of his brand. Can do man, sharp and compassionate, and the stores carry his name as the Brand. He is banking his power as an Australian Icon will carry him through this battle. The feedback from web 2.0 is that he is wrong.
It will be interesting to see if he steps back, or continues to push. Its a battle that will be hard to win, in an unwinable war.
Consumerism in Australia is not ‘fundamental’ like other Western capitalist democracies. Australian’s are more resistant to brand marketing, and conspicuous consumption - outside housing. This resistance has relaxed with the booming economy over the last 10 years, and the influx of migrants with more comsumerist attitudes, but with the GFC, Aussies started saving and paying down debt, and lo and behold, looking for better deals. Those values are not far beneath the surface, and rising.
Now is the time for innovation, not recrimination… eCommerce is here to stay.
Tags: Marketing, Trends, Opinion by admin
No Comments »